Authors submit their manuscripts to the relevant journal for initial consideration.

The Editor-in-Chief (EIC) assesses the manuscript’s scope, relevance, and basic quality. Manuscripts that do not meet the journal’s criteria may be rejected or recommended for transfer to a more suitable journal within Crystal Scientific Publishers.

Each manuscript undergoes a two-step check using advanced software tools and manual evaluation. Manuscripts that pass proceed to peer review.

Eligible manuscripts are assigned to qualified reviewers. The double-blind process is intended to support impartial evaluation.

Reviewers assess originality, technical accuracy, relevance, and contribution to the field. Their comments and recommendations are sent to the EIC.

Authors revise their manuscripts in response to reviewer comments and resubmit the revised version for further evaluation.

The revised manuscript may be reviewed again by reviewers or assessed by the EIC. The EIC makes the final decision:

• Accepted: the manuscript meets the journal’s quality and scientific requirements.
• Rejected or transferred: it does not meet the required standards or may be more suitable for another journal in the publisher’s portfolio.

After acceptance, the manuscript moves to final formatting and production. The article is then published and made available to readers worldwide.